California Poised To Strengthen Mental Health Insurance Laws

Enlarge this image

Los Angeles County last fall unveiled one of its 10 Department of Mental Health vans aimed at, among other things, reducing long waiting periods for the transport of individuals experiencing a serious mental health crisis. The California legislature made its own bid this week to expand access to mental health care statewide.

Damian Dovarganes/AP

hide caption

toggle caption

Damian Dovarganes/AP

Shots — Health News
‘Mental Health Parity’ Is Still An Elusive Goal In U.S. Insurance Coverage

«All of a sudden his behavior started changing to the point that he was no longer a friendly, happy-go-lucky kid, says Vera-Schubert. She’s a pharmacist, but it still took her a while to recognize what was happening. He raided his grandparents’ medicine cabinet and his mother’s jewelry box to feed his growing addiction. His drug dealer went to his high school.

Where Vera-Schubert lives, in Burbank, Calif., state laws as well as federal already require insurance companies to cover mental health as they do medical care. Even so, she encountered multiple hurdles to get coverage for her son’s visits to rehab or for medication. Often she had very narrow windows of time between her son agreeing to go to treatment, and getting him checked in, she says. Once, her insurance pre-authorized her son for in-patient rehabilitation treatment, but when he showed up, the paperwork had not yet been filed. He waited several hours in the lobby. Then left.

«My son walked, says Vera-Schubert, who was then tormented by fear she might lose him before he got treatment. «He walked home to his grandparents house and he goes, ‘I’m never going back there again.’ «

She says her private insurance put up other roadblocks as well: long waiting periods; requirements that couldn’t get help unless he tested positive for drugs. Paying for the in-patient rehab out-of-pocket would have cost her nearly $50,000 for a 28-day stay.

Shots — Health News
A New Addiction Crisis: Treatment Centers Face Financial Collapse

«It felt terrible and overwhelming, she says, sobbing. «So overwhelming how many times I had to fight for my son.

Bobby Schubert, now 25, eventually received treatment and entered recovery just over a year ago, but only after receiving advice to get off his mother’s private insurance plan, and getting on Medi-Cal, California’s public Medicaid program.

Scott Weiner, the California senator who introduced the bill, says it’s critical to focus on preventative care.

«We need to beyond giving insurance coverage only when someone is in crisis and going to the psych emergency room, he says. «We need to get people mental health and addiction help early, when we can nip it in the bud, before they lose their job, before they lose their housing, before they lose their family. And we need to get people the care they need.

Shots — Health News
Flood Of Calls And Texts To Crisis Hotlines Reflects Americans’ Rising Anxiety

Shots — Health News
Act Now To Get Ahead Of A Mental Health Crisis, Specialists Advise U.S.

Meanwhile, the insurance industry says the bill California’s legislature passed Sunday is a misguided effort to fix the wrong problem.

In a statement, the California Association of Health Plans says arguments that mental health treatment isn’t already on par with medical care in terms of insurance reimbursement «couldn’t be further from the truth — and that language in the bill could end up limiting treatment options. It says meeting growing demand for care will require an investment in a bigger mental health workforce, among other things, which the bill does not address.

America’s Health Insurance Plans, national association, also has argued that the bill the legislature has proposed is unnecessary and would add to administrative costs. It says the industry is already in compliance with the law.

Patrick Kennedy, a former U.S. congressman from Rhode Island, turned mental health advocate, co-authored the landmark 2008 federal law, and disagrees with that argument from the insurance industry.

«The fact is that they are not covering it, Kennedy says, «and it’s discriminatory to people who are suffering from mental illness and addiction — especially at a time when our country is crying out over an epidemic of overdoses and suicides.

Kennedy says the California bill — if signed into law — could become a model for other states, and prompt insurance companies to change policies nationally.

Disputes over mental health parity are also playing out in court.

Last year, United Behavioral Health lost a class-action suit brought by patients arguing the insurance giant improperly denied coverage.

«The biggest tool insurers have to deny claims is to say treatment is not «medically necessary, says Meiram Bendat, who is both the plaintiff’s co-counsel on that case and a Los Angeles-based psychotherapist.

Bendat says the new California proposal would address one gaping problem: It would no longer allow insurers to write their own rules about what to cover. It would also create incentives for insurers to expand the network of therapists, counselors and psychiatrists that take their insurance.

He says many of the patients he represented were denied inpatient addiction treatment. «They couldn’t afford the care; they didn’t get the care; they overdosed and died. And there is absolutely no ability to get punitive damages, he says, because that was not a remedy under federal law. Without that, says Bendat, insurers had little incentive to change their practices.

The bill passed by the legislature is now on California Governor Gavin Newsom’s desk, and he has 30 days to sign it. His office declined to comment to NPR about whether or when he intends to sign it into law.